Enode Developers
Create accountLog in

Webhooks

Webhooks are a mechanism that allows your server to receive notifications of events from the Enode system.

Currently, only one webhook is available - a preconfigured webhook called Firehose that reports all supported events occurring within the system. You can configure it using the Update Firehose WebhookAPI endpoint.

One webhook payload will contain up to 100 webhook events.

We will periodically send heartbeat events to your webhook to check its availability and inform you how many events you have queued for delivery. Under normal operations, this number is close to zero.

Copy linkVersioning

Your client API version controls the webhook behavior. Every event contains a version attribute that indicates the version used to generate the payload. We recommend you use this attribute in your webhook handler to future-proof your implementation, making it easier for you to handle future version changes.

Copy linkIntegrating webhooks

Webhook deliveries time out after 5 seconds, so you must respond with a 200 OK as fast as possible and offload processing to an async worker, queue, or background thread following industry best practices. Some examples of this are the Github Docs, Shopify Docs and Stripe Docs.

Enode will attempt to deliver your events up to 18 times over 26 hours in increasing intervals, after which all events will be deleted and your webhook marked as offline. Any success will reset this counter back to 0.

If your webhook gets marked as invalid, it can be reactivated in one of 3 ways:

Copy linkSupported events

NameDescription
user:vehicle:discoveredA new vehicle has been discovered attached to a user
user:vehicle:updatedOne or more of a vehicle's properties (as listed in Get VehicleAPI) has been updated
user:vehicle:deletedA vehicle has been deleted
user:vehicle:smart-charging-status-updatedA vehicle's SmartChargingStatus has updated
user:schedule:execution-updatedA schedule's status has updated
user:vendor-action:updatedAn action has changed state
user:charge-action:updatedAn action has changed state. This is DEPRECATED in favour of user:vendor-action:updated.
system:heartbeatA heartbeat event is sent every 10 minutes to assure that webhook delivery is active
user:charger:discoveredA new charger has been discovered attached to a user
user:charger:updatedOne or more of a charger's properties has been updated
user:charger:deletedA charger has been deleted
user:hvac:discoveredA new HVAC has been discovered attached to a user
user:hvac:updatedOne or more of an HVAC's properties has been updated
user:hvac:deletedAn HVAC has been deleted
user:inverter:discoveredA new inverted has been discovered attached to a user
user:inverter:updatedOne or more of a inverter's properties has been updated
user:inverter:deletedAn inverter has been deleted
user:credentials:invalidatedA user credential was marked as invalid

Copy linkImplementing your webhook endpoint

Your webhook endpoint should expect to receive POST requests bearing the following headers:

HeaderDescription
X-Enode-DeliveryUnique ID identifying the delivered payload
X-Enode-SignatureSignature authenticating that Enode is the author of the delivery

And an application/json body containing an array of Events, with the following schema:

Sample

[
  {
    "event": "user:vehicle:updated", // String - name of the event
    "createdAt": "2020-04-07T17:04:26Z", // UTC ISO 8601 - time at which the event was triggered
  },
  ...
]

Each Event object may contain additional properties, depending on the event.

Copy linkGenerating a secret

A cryptographically secure secret should be generated and persisted on your server.

When you call Update Firehose WebhookAPI, the secret must be provided. We use the secret to generate a signature on each webhook request. See Verifying a payload signature for instructions on using the secret to verify that the request originated from Enode.

It should be a pseudorandom value of at least 128 bits produced by a secure generator.

Sample

// Node.js example - 256 bits
const crypto = require("crypto");
const secret = crypto.randomBytes(32).toString("hex");

Copy linkVerifying a payload signature

Requests to your endpoint will bear an X-Enode-Signature header verifying that the request has come from us.

The signature is the HMAC hex digest of the payload, where:

  • algorithm = sha1
  • key = your secret provided during webhook configuration
  • payload = The request body (a UTF-8 encoded string containing JSON - be sure not to deserialize it before signature computation)

The signature is then prefixed with "sha1=". A delivery of {"payload":"example"} signed with example-secret would have an X-Enode-Signature of sha1=e417e6fc2e7f8a78c93a35a7b344d36ce179fc8d.

In Javascript, the signature may be verified as follows:

Sample

// Node.js + Express example

// Read signature from request HTTP header
const enodeSignature = Buffer.from(req.get("X-Enode-Signature"), "utf8");

// Compute signature using your secret and the request payload
const payload = req.body;
const hmac = crypto.createHmac("sha1", <your secret>);
const digest = Buffer.from("sha1=" + hmac.update(payload).digest("hex"), "utf8");

// Check whether they match, using timing-safe equality (don't use ==)
if (!crypto.timingSafeEqual(digest, enodeSignature)) {
  throw new Error("Signature invalid");
}

Copy linkExample deliveries

The updatedFields value is a list of keys within the vehicle value whose change triggered this update event.

Copy linkuser:vehicle:discovered

Delivery containing 1 user:vehicle:discovered event.

The vehicle value follows the same response schema as Get VehicleAPI.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:vehicle:discovered",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T13:22:22.919Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "29a89ebd-7f42-4469-b471-a13d81a4ab16"
    },
    "vehicle": {
      "smartChargingPolicy": {
        "isEnabled": false,
        "deadline": null
      },
      "chargeState": {
        "isPluggedIn": null,
        "isCharging": null,
        "batteryLevel": null,
        "range": null,
        "isChargingReasons": ["DEFAULT"],
        "batteryCapacity": null,
        "chargeLimit": null,
        "chargeRate": null,
        "chargeTimeRemaining": null,
        "lastUpdated": null,
        "isFullyCharged": false
      },
      "location": {
        "latitude": null,
        "longitude": null,
        "lastUpdated": null
      },
      "information": {
        "id": "2a2134bf-13ff-4bd3-beca-d1cdc360cbb9",
        "brand": "Tesla",
        "model": "Tesla Model S",
        "year": 2021
      },
      "odometer": {
        "distance": null,
        "lastUpdated": null
      },
      "capabilities": {
        "chargeState": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "information": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "location": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "odometer": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "startCharging": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "stopCharging": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "smartCharging": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        }
      },
      "id": "2a2134bf-13ff-4bd3-beca-d1cdc360cbb9",
      "isReachable": false,
      "lastSeen": null,
      "chargingLocationId": null
    }
  }
]

Copy linkuser:vehicle:updated

Delivery containing 1 user:vehicle:updated event.

The vehicle value follows the same response schema as Get VehicleAPI.

The updatedFields value is a list of keys within the vehicle value whose change triggered this update event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:vehicle:updated",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T13:22:22.954Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "29a89ebd-7f42-4469-b471-a13d81a4ab16"
    },
    "vehicle": {
      "smartChargingPolicy": {
        "isEnabled": false,
        "deadline": null
      },
      "chargeState": {
        "isPluggedIn": null,
        "isCharging": null,
        "batteryLevel": null,
        "range": null,
        "isChargingReasons": ["DEFAULT"],
        "powerDeliveryState": "UNKNOWN",
        "batteryCapacity": null,
        "chargeLimit": null,
        "chargeRate": null,
        "chargeTimeRemaining": null,
        "lastUpdated": null,
        "isFullyCharged": false
      },
      "location": {
        "latitude": null,
        "longitude": null,
        "lastUpdated": null
      },
      "information": {
        "id": "2a2134bf-13ff-4bd3-beca-d1cdc360cbb9",
        "brand": "Tesla",
        "model": "Test vehicle",
        "year": 2021
      },
      "odometer": {
        "distance": null,
        "lastUpdated": null
      },
      "capabilities": {
        "chargeState": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "information": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "location": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "odometer": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "startCharging": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "stopCharging": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "smartCharging": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        }
      },
      "id": "2a2134bf-13ff-4bd3-beca-d1cdc360cbb9",
      "isReachable": false,
      "lastSeen": null,
      "chargingLocationId": null
    },
    "updatedFields": ["information.model"]
  }
]

Copy linkuser:vehicle:deleted

Delivery containing 1 user:vehicle:deleted event.

The vehicle value follows the same response schema as Get VehicleAPI.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:vehicle:deleted",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T13:22:22.968Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "29a89ebd-7f42-4469-b471-a13d81a4ab16"
    },
    "vehicle": {
      "smartChargingPolicy": {
        "isEnabled": false,
        "deadline": null
      },
      "chargeState": {
        "isPluggedIn": null,
        "isCharging": null,
        "batteryLevel": null,
        "range": null,
        "isChargingReasons": ["DEFAULT"],
        "batteryCapacity": null,
        "chargeLimit": null,
        "chargeRate": null,
        "chargeTimeRemaining": null,
        "lastUpdated": null,
        "isFullyCharged": false
      },
      "location": {
        "latitude": null,
        "longitude": null,
        "lastUpdated": null
      },
      "information": {
        "id": "2a2134bf-13ff-4bd3-beca-d1cdc360cbb9",
        "brand": "Tesla",
        "model": "Test vehicle",
        "year": 2021
      },
      "odometer": {
        "distance": null,
        "lastUpdated": null
      },
      "capabilities": {
        "chargeState": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "information": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "location": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "odometer": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "startCharging": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "stopCharging": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        },
        "smartCharging": {
          "interventionIds": [],
          "isCapable": true
        }
      },
      "id": "2a2134bf-13ff-4bd3-beca-d1cdc360cbb9",
      "isReachable": false,
      "lastSeen": null,
      "chargingLocationId": null
    }
  }
]

Copy linkuser:vehicle:smart-charging-status-updated

Delivery containing 1 user:vehicle:smart-charging-status-updated event.

The smartChargingStatus value follows the same response schema as Get Smart Charging StatusAPI.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:vehicle:smart-charging-status-updated",
    "createdAt": "2020-04-07T17:04:26Z",
    "smartChargingStatus": {
      "updatedAt": "2021-06-29T00:00:00Z",
      "vehicleId": "VEHICLE-XYZ",
      "userId": "USER-XYZ",
      "vendor": "TESLA",
      "state": "CONSIDERING",
      "stateChangedAt": "2021-06-29T00:00:00Z",
      "consideration": {
        "atChargingLocation": true,
        "confidentBatteryCapacity": true,
        "confidentTimeEstimate": true,
        "hasChargeAboveThreshold": true,
        "hasTimeEstimate": true,
        "isCharging": false,
        "isNormalSchedule": true,
        "isPluggedIn": false,
        "isSmartChargeCapable": true,
        "locationIsFresh": true,
        "minimumDelay": true,
        "minimumSavings": true,
        "needsCharge": true,
        "needsSignificantCharge": true,
        "noCommittedDelay": true,
        "priceDataAvailable": true,
        "singleUser": true
      },
      "plan": null
    },
    "updatedFields": [
      // list of fields that have changed on the smartChargingStatus object
      "consideration.hasTimeEstimate"
    ]
  }
]

Copy linkuser:schedule:execution-updated

The schedule value follows the same response schema as Get ScheduleAPI, and the status value follows the same response schema as Get Schedule StatusAPI.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:schedule:execution-updated",
    "createdAt": "2021-10-13T13:08:12.125Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "41db4c1f-66c0-4a57-b318-7a853972bb83"
    },
    "schedule": {
      "id": "89282680-ee9e-4351-aa88-a3d8c74d9d45",
      "chargingLocationId": null,
      "targetId": "1231sd3d2332f223423",
      "targetType": "vehicle",
      "defaultShouldCharge": false,
      "isEnabled": true,
      "rules": [
        {
          "hourMinute": {
            "to": "16:00",
            "from": "15:00"
          },
          "shouldCharge": true
        }
      ]
    },
    "status": {
      "scheduleId": "89282680-ee9e-4351-aa88-a3d8c74d9d45",
      "state": "INACTIVE:INCAPABLE",
      "changedAt": "2021-10-13T09:48:29.069Z",
      "isCharging": false,
      "isChargingExpected": false,
      "isChargingExpectedParts": {
        "isPluggedIn": false,
        "needsCharge": true,
        "shouldCharge": false
      },
      "upcomingTransitions": [
        {
          "at": "2021-10-13T15:00:00.000Z",
          "shouldCharge": true
        },
        {
          "at": "2021-10-13T16:00:00.000Z",
          "shouldCharge": false
        }
      ]
    },
    // List of changed field inside status
    "updatedFields": ["changedAt", "state"]
  }
]

Copy linkuser:vendor-action:updated

The vendorAction value follows the same response schema as Post Charger Charging ActionAPI and Post Vehicle Charging ActionAPI.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:vendor-action:updated",
    "createdAt": "2021-10-13T13:08:12.125Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "41db4c1f-66c0-4a57-b318-7a853972bb83"
    },
    "vendorAction": {
      "id": "89282680-ee9e-4351-aa88-a3d8c74d9d45",
      "targetId": "1231sd3d2332f223423",
      "targetType": "vehicle",
      "kind": "START",
      "state": "CONFIRMED",
      "createdAt": "2021-10-13T13:04:13.155Z",
      "updatedAt": "2021-10-13T13:08:12.125Z",
      "completedAt": "2021-10-13T13:08:12.125Z"
    },
    // List of changed fields inside vendorAction
    "updatedFields": ["changedAt", "state"]
  }
]

Copy linkuser:charge-action:updated

This is a deprecated event and is replaced by user:vendor-action:updated. The event name and some nested keys were changed to align with adding HVAC device actions. During the transition period, we will send duplicate user:charge-action:updated and user:vendor-actions:updated events, but only for vehicles and chargers.

Copy linkuser:charger:discovered

Delivery containing 1 user:charger:discovered event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:charger:discovered",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.456Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "cb4e983f-a838-41f8-ae33-852701c2d3e6"
    },
    "charger": {
      "id": "39e9f095-de5f-4acc-b964-9ef7563debc7",
      "lastSeen": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.450Z",
      "isReachable": false,
      "chargeState": {
        "isPluggedIn": false,
        "isCharging": false,
        "chargeRate": null,
        "powerDeliveryState": "UNPLUGGED",
        "lastUpdated": null
      },
      "information": {
        "id": "39e9f095-de5f-4acc-b964-9ef7563debc7",
        "brand": "Wallbox",
        "model": "Pulsar Plus",
        "year": 2021
      }
    }
  }
]

Copy linkuser:charger:updated

Delivery containing 1 user:charger:updated event.

The updatedFields value is a list of keys within the charger value whose change triggered this update event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:charger:updated",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.479Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "cb4e983f-a838-41f8-ae33-852701c2d3e6"
    },
    "charger": {
      "id": "39e9f095-de5f-4acc-b964-9ef7563debc7",
      "lastSeen": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.450Z",
      "isReachable": false,
      "chargeState": {
        "isPluggedIn": true,
        "isCharging": false,
        "powerDeliveryState": "PLUGGED_IN:STOPPED",
        "chargeRate": null,
        "lastUpdated": null
      },
      "information": {
        "id": "39e9f095-de5f-4acc-b964-9ef7563debc7",
        "brand": "Wallbox",
        "model": "Pulsar Plus",
        "year": 2021
      }
    },
    "updatedFields": [
      "chargeState.isPluggedIn",
      "chargeState.powerDeliveryState"
    ]
  }
]

Copy linkuser:charger:deleted

Delivery containing 1 user:charger:deleted event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:charger:deleted",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.491Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "c1edc7bf-c8a7-4ae2-9258-12e98332e039"
    },
    "charger": {
      "id": "39e9f095-de5f-4acc-b964-9ef7563debc7",
      "chargeState": {
        "isCharging": false,
        "lastUpdated": null
      },
      "information": {
        "id": "39e9f095-de5f-4acc-b964-9ef7563debc7"
      }
    }
  }
]

Copy linksystem:heartbeat

Delivery containing 1 system:heartbeat event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "system:heartbeat",
    "createdAt": "2020-04-07T17:04:26Z",
    "pendingEvents": 0 // the number of events currently pending delivery via webhook
  }
]

Copy linkuser:hvac:discovered

Delivery containing 1 user:hvac:discovered event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:hvac:discovered",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.491Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "54d421ca-0d16-450f-984b-00200dcd7ef5"
    },
    "hvac": {
      "id": "5bd6b882-0691-4ceb-98a8-238c653aceb6",
      "lastSeen": "2021-12-21T17:49:03.586Z",
      "isReachable": true,
      "chargingLocationId": null,
      "isActive": false,
      "currentTemperature": 19,
      "targetTemperature": 18,
      "consumptionRate": 0,
      "information": {
        "brand": "Mill",
        "model": "Mill Glass WiFi panel heater 1200W",
        "displayName": "Kitchen heater",
        "groupName": "Hallway",
        "category": "HEATING"
      }
    }
  }
]

Copy linkuser:hvac:updated

Delivery containing 1 user:hvac:updated event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:hvac:updated",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.491Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "54d421ca-0d16-450f-984b-00200dcd7ef5"
    },
    "hvac": {
      "id": "5bd6b882-0691-4ceb-98a8-238c653aceb6",
      "lastSeen": "2021-12-21T17:49:03.586Z",
      "isReachable": true,
      "chargingLocationId": "eb9d2d12-5d21-4e95-bee1-731658d259a0",
      "isActive": false,
      "consumptionRate": 0,
      "currentTemperature": 19,
      "targetTemperature": {
        "deadband": 2,
        "temperature": 20
      },
      "information": {
        "brand": "Mill",
        "model": "Mill Glass WiFi panel heater 1200W",
        "displayName": "Kitchen heater",
        "groupName": "Hallway",
        "category": "HEATING"
      }
    },
    "updatedFields": ["chargingLocationId"]
  }
]

Copy linkuser:hvac:deleted

Delivery containing 1 user:hvac:deleted event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:hvac:deleted",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.491Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "54d421ca-0d16-450f-984b-00200dcd7ef5"
    },
    "hvac": {
      "id": "5bd6b882-0691-4ceb-98a8-238c653aceb6",
      "lastSeen": "2021-12-21T17:49:03.586Z",
      "isReachable": true,
      "chargingLocationId": "eb9d2d12-5d21-4e95-bee1-731658d259a0",
      "isActive": false,
      "currentTemperature": 19,
      "targetTemperature": 18,
      "consumptionRate": 0,
      "information": {
        "brand": "Mill",
        "model": "Mill Glass WiFi panel heater 1200W",
        "displayName": "Kitchen heater",
        "groupName": "Hallway",
        "category": "HEATING"
      }
    }
  }
]

Copy linkuser:inverter:discovered

Delivery containing 1 user:inverter:discovered event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:inverter:discovered",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.491Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "54d421ca-0d16-450f-984b-00200dcd7ef5"
    },
    "inverter": {
      "id": "238759d3-2d85-43d9-82e1-3cb0062c0257",
      "vendor": "FRONIUS",
      "chargingLocationId": null,
      "lastSeen": "2022-04-07T17:04:26Z",
      "isReachable": true,
      "productionState": {
        "productionRate": 1.8,
        "isProducing": true,
        "lastUpdated": "2022-04-07T16:21:76Z"
      },
      "information": {
        "id": "8d90101b-3f2f-462a-bbb4-1ed320d33bbe",
        "brand": "SMA",
        "model": "Sunny Boy",
        "siteName": "Sunny plant",
        "installationDate": "2020-04-05"
      },
      "location": {
        "longitude": 10.757933,
        "latitude": 59.911491
      }
    }
  }
]

Copy linkuser:inverter:updated

Delivery containing 1 user:inverter:updated event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:inverter:updated",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.491Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "54d421ca-0d16-450f-984b-00200dcd7ef5"
    },
    "inverter": {
      "id": "238759d3-2d85-43d9-82e1-3cb0062c0257",
      "vendor": "FRONIUS",
      "chargingLocationId": "8d90101b-3f2f-462a-bbb4-1ed320d33bbe",
      "lastSeen": "2022-04-07T17:04:26Z",
      "isReachable": true,
      "productionState": {
        "productionRate": 1.8,
        "isProducing": true,
        "lastUpdated": "2022-04-07T16:21:76Z"
      },
      "information": {
        "id": "8d90101b-3f2f-462a-bbb4-1ed320d33bbe",
        "brand": "SMA",
        "model": "Sunny Boy",
        "siteName": "Sunny plant",
        "installationDate": "2020-04-05"
      },
      "location": {
        "longitude": 10.757933,
        "latitude": 59.911491
      }
    },
    "updatedFields": ["chargingLocationId"]
  }
]

Copy linkuser:inverter:deleted

Delivery containing 1 user:inverter:deleted event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:inverter:deleted",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.491Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "54d421ca-0d16-450f-984b-00200dcd7ef5"
    },
    "inverter": {
      "id": "238759d3-2d85-43d9-82e1-3cb0062c0257",
      "vendor": "FRONIUS",
      "chargingLocationId": "8d90101b-3f2f-462a-bbb4-1ed320d33bbe",
      "lastSeen": "2022-04-07T17:04:26Z",
      "isReachable": true,
      "productionState": {
        "productionRate": 1.8,
        "isProducing": true,
        "lastUpdated": "2022-04-07T16:21:76Z"
      },
      "information": {
        "id": "8d90101b-3f2f-462a-bbb4-1ed320d33bbe",
        "brand": "SMA",
        "model": "Sunny Boy",
        "siteName": "Sunny plant",
        "installationDate": "2020-04-05"
      },
      "location": {
        "longitude": 10.757933,
        "latitude": 59.911491
      }
    }
  }
]

Copy linkuser:credentials:invalidated

Delivery containing 1 user:credentials:invalidated event.

Sample

[
  {
    "version": "2023-02-01",
    "event": "user:credentials:invalidated",
    "createdAt": "2021-12-03T12:53:24.491Z",
    "user": {
      "id": "54d421ca-0d16-450f-984b-00200dcd7ef5"
    },
    "vendor": "TESLA"
  }
]
Was this article helpful?